In this chapter, we will discuss the cost of poor quality which is something even the best companies struggle to get a handle on. What are these costs? They are all of the costs both visible and hidden that eat into the profit margins of an organization. Cost of poor quality could include activities that don’t meet the desired outcomes or activities that are inefficient. Maybe we are achieving acceptable quality, but it takes us a long time to do it, so our operation is too slow. Or perhaps we’re utilizing a lot of resources on rework instead of making our deliverable right the first time. There is a calculation for the cost of poor quality. It is the actual cost minus the minimum cost. If we did everything correctly and efficiently the first time, that would be our minimum cost. Then we figure out what we are actually spending. The difference between them helps us to determine the cost of poor quality. There are many types of cost in the area of cost of poor quality. The most severe ones are when the customers reject the deliverable. At that point, we have already created the entire deliverable and shipped it. It is in the hands of the customer, who will be dissatisfied.
There will be repair costs, rework, and testing costs, but it goes well beyond that. What about the impact to our reputation in the market? Are we utilizing our resources efficiently? How much time and money do we spend on corrective actions to make the customer happy? Not to mention the confusion and the loss of motivation to our employees. The cost of poor quality can really add up. We can use statistics to interpret the cost of poor quality measure. It’s important to understand that for a non-Six Sigma process, the cost of poor quality can be extremely high. I was once working with one of the world’s most highly recognized and reputable insurance firms with their defined benefits organization. They were looking at a process that included about 140 different process steps, from the time somebody retired, to when we cut the first check for the retirement. We went through the process, and I asked everybody to add up the time spent across the entire process with respect to inspection, rework and verification, and steps that weren’t right the first time. They were shocked to find out that 65% of the total cost of the process was due to some type of corruption or rework throughout the entire process. Pretty scary. A company running at four sigma can see as much a 20% of sales revenues being lost. If we’re at five sigma, we’re doing a whole lot better than that with closer to 10% lost. Despite our best efforts, some of the largest companies in the world could easily be operating at $8 to $12 billion in losses per year due to cost of poor quality. Next, we will work to establish a baseline and a goal to address the cost of poor quality.
We can use the DMAIC cycle to do this. At the define stage, we determine what our current sigma level is in order to understand our true current cost of quality. This may include doing some measurement and data collection to set an accurate baseline. This will allow us to create a clear project charter about what we are trying to accomplish and provide the basis to track the benefits after our project. We can also use the baseline of cost to poor quality to prioritize the portfolio projects, so we know which projects to take on to maximize the benefits to the organization. You and your team may find it helpful to keep a Six Sigma conversion table on hand. In this case, if we determine our yield or the proportion of deliverable with no defects, we can also determine how many defects per million opportunities are in our process. This allows us to then identify which sigma we are operating at. For example, if our yield is .945, we can determine that this indicates a 3.10 sigma. In terms of cost of poor quality, our operation has exposure of 30% for the cost of poor quality for the organization. As we improve to 3.5 sigma, still as much as 20% of our production is being lost as waste. At 4.6 sigma we lose 10%, and at 4.98 sigma, we are at 5% waste. But it doesn’t stop there. As we improve our sigma performance and drive down the cost of poor quality, we should also consider how this benefits us in other ways. For example, what do you suppose the impact of customer satisfaction would be as we increase the sigma? What about the impact on market share and top line growth? If you’re moving from 30% to 10% or less cost of poor quality, you’re going to see multiple benefits for the entire organization.