In this chapter, we will explore the concept of value added. Value is defined by how well a product or service actually meets our customer’s requirements. An important question we can ask to determine value is, will the customer be willing to pay for this? If the answer to that is clearly yes, then we can argue that it has value. So value added includes activities that actually add value to the end product, and that our customer is willing to pay for. So logically, we would say that non-value added would be any activities the customer is unwilling to pay for. So let’s say we provided a detailed invoice to our customer, and we broke down every single activity that was included in the price. If the customer was able to cross off anything and say hey, I don’t want to pay for that in my price, that would help us to identify the non-value added activities. Let’s explore this in more detail. There is a very helpful three point test. We can break down each activity in the process, perhaps using value stream mapping. For each activity we ask three critical questions. Does it fulfill our customer’s need or preference? Does it physically change something about the product or service? And is it done right the first time? We have to say yes to all three of these questions or this step in the process may not add so much value.
For example, let’s say you went shopping for an article of clothing, and you had a coupon with you for a discount. If you take the clothing and the coupon to the checkout and they quickly and efficiently scan it and you receive instant savings, that’s value added. And they’re actually doing it right the first time. However, if they have to stop and go find a supervisor to get approval or go research it someplace before they can give you your discount. You probably would not see that as value added activity because of the delay and not getting it right the first time. Let’s discuss non-value add activities. Just because we mark something as non-value add, doesn’t mean we can necessarily scrap it. For example, with physical items we may repurpose it, recycle it, or sell it at a discount. Or maybe it’s something we have to do because it’s necessary to operate the business, or it’s a regulatory standard. We also have to support activities such as human relations, information technology, finance, and legal could fall on this category. Or maybe our customers have given us mandates that require additional inspections or documentation before we can provide that product or service.
There will always be some non-value add activities that we just can’t change easily. The concept of Lean includes the classic seven wastes. Let’s start with overproduction. This is any effort beyond what’s required to meet the customer’s requirements. Building inventory or having a bunch of people sitting around waiting for a phone call is a form of that. After that, we have extra processing, which can include reworking a product or service. Motion would be the physical movement of people, material, and information that’s taking up time or space, but not really adding value. Waiting would be delays, both planned and unplanned, that consume time and money, but don’t really add value in the opinion of our customer. Transportation would be trucking, logistics, and shipping in excess of the minimal requirement needed to deliver to the customer. Inventory would be excessive inventory beyond just what’s needed to support a smooth pull of production of information through the value stream. And then finally, any defects. This includes any need to fix, repair, scrap, or otherwise correct and inspect that could be avoided by doing it right the first time.