The tools used in the Lean and Six Sigma methodologies overlap significantly, although each toolbox has some methods and tools the other doesn’t use.
For example, Lean relies on pull scheduling, setup reduction, and seven wastes. Six Sigma uses Design of Experiments (DOE) and hypothesis tests to improve quality.
Both approaches, however, rely on improvement methodologies and common techniques for problem solving and root cause identification, such as the 5 Whys and process mapping.
Six Sigma comes equipped with a large toolkit of prescribed tools and methods to use for each phase in the DMAIC roadmap.
Increasingly, as Lean and Six Sigma are combined into an integrated methodology, tools that were formerly specific to Lean are being used within Six Sigma with great success.
Some of the specific Lean tools that are being used in Six Sigma include:
- value stream maps (VSM)
- lead time and takt time
- seven wastes tool
- 5S methodology, JIT and kanban
- visual control tools, kaizen, and poka-yoke
In the Define phase, the project team is concerned with defining the problem, the project goals, and customer deliverables. A required deliverable of the Define phase is the process map.
In the Lean Six Sigma methodology, the process map is being replaced by Lean’s more robust value stream map (VSM). The VSM illustrates process flow, people, inventory, queue times, and process lead times; it is especially useful if the Six Sigma metric is time based.
During the Measure phase of Six Sigma DMAIC, using lead time and takt time metrics, which are valuable Lean tools, to measure the performance of current process is a good idea. Lead time measures the time between the initiation of a process and the completion of the process. Takt time is the amount of time available to produce a unit of product as required by the customer. Too much variation between the two times indicates a problem.
During the Analyze phase, the project team analyzes and determines the root causes of the defects.
The Lean seven wastes tool can help the team quickly identify potential waste in the process. Often, these wastes are merely a symptom of larger problems, including broken processes.
During the Improve phase, the 5S methodology (sort, store, shine, standardize, and sustain) can help improve a process and eliminate waste through organization, cleanliness, and workplace standardization.
JIT and kanban tools are used to effect inventory reduction and control. Variation in inventory management processes is a common cause of problems; thus, JIT-kanban tools could be useful to a Six Sigma process improvement team.
Finally, during the Control phase, Lean visual controls, kaizen, and poka-yoke are useful tools for controlling future performance.
Visual control tools, such as charts and schedule boards, help to maintain control over processes.
Kaizen is a method for continuously improving a process through incremental steps, rather than through a leap caused by re-engineering or redesigning a process. Using the kaizen philosophy helps to maintain improvements.
Poka-yoke is an analytic approach that involves analyzing a process to uncover where human errors could occur and then implementing a workaround or procedure that will prevent the errors from occurring.