Each organization requires a different mix of Lean and Six Sigma approaches, depending on its needs. For companies that require the benefits of both, the best approach is to adopt Lean first and then adopt Six Sigma.
Attempting to adopt both methodologies in parallel causes confusion, and sometimes makes one methodology dominant at the expense of the other.
Starting with Lean has a number of advantages. With Lean, the organization can quickly standardize its basic flow, eliminate nonvalue-added steps, and reduce inventory. The quick-win opportunities and cost savings realized through Lean prove the benefits of process improvement and motivate workers to buy in to process improvement.
The short-term Lean improvement projects usually reveal deeper and more pervasive problems that Lean tools and methods cannot address. At this point, Six Sigma can be implemented to address the more pervasive problems with its robust tools and methods.
A year after implementing Lean, a U.S. maker of playground equipment had cut lead time by 22%, improved productivity by more than 10%, and reduced wastes from 0.8% to 0.2%.
Then, workers got a big surprise. A defect in their processes was creating holes in the PVC-coated pipes and causing a very high incidence of scrap. Lean tools were not adequate for identifying the cause of the defects, so the company implemented Six Sigma, which provided the robust tools and approach needed to identify the cause of the problem, analyze it, improve the situation, and control the improvements.
The integrated Lean Six Sigma methodology combines the best of both worlds. As a process begins to show improvement, Lean directs you to move on to the next project. Six Sigma requires continual revisiting to ensure the process remains improved.
When implementing Lean Six Sigma, it’s important to have a plan and a strategy. As part of this strategy, the organization must:
- engage management at the executive and strategic level in defining the targets for improvements
- monitor the initiative
- obtain employee buy-in
In addition to monitoring processes, monitoring the initiative itself is critical. The improvement plan is not set in stone. Priorities change. You must ensure that the plan remains current by updating it to reflect the realities of your business.
Too many initiatives lose steam when their plans become irrelevant through lack of attention. Without continuous monitoring, the initiative won’t get your organization where it needs to go.
Senior managers must demonstrate their commitment and provide strong, ongoing support. Then, from the worker level up, the methodologies must be understood and implemented. Lean and Six Sigma must be used consistently – not once in a while, nor in a start-and-stop fashion.
Management at the executive and strategic levels must be involved in defining where and how to focus Lean and Six Sigma efforts, based on the organization’s needs, and the tools and methods of each approach.
As Lean directs the improvement effort from one process to the next, management must establish procedures for monitoring the improved processes. Without monitoring, backsliding can occur, and these improved processes end up where they were before.
A last strategic consideration for your implementation, and one of the most important, is to ensure that all members of your Lean Six Sigma implementation team buy in to the process improvement initiative.
Employees who use the processes are in the best position to identify opportunities for improvement. Ideally, they will take responsibility for their processes and monitor them to ensure improvements are permanent. There is a direct correlation between employee participation in process improvement and their attitudes toward their jobs and the company.
The owner of an auto parts manufacturing company wants to grow his business by 50%. Before he approaches financial institutions to borrow funds, he wants to improve his operations.
Business Needs
The owner wants to employ a quick, relatively inexpensive strategy to squeeze waste out of his processes and reduce lead time to a minimum.
Strategy
The owner’s best strategy is to implement Lean, which will produce the kind of quick gains he requires.
If serious defects are found during Lean’s kaizen events, the owner may need to think about a more long-term strategy, such as implementing Six Sigma as well.
The executive board of a diversified chemicals and plastic manufacturing company in the United States, Europe, and Asia has made a large commitment of time and money to continuous process improvement.
Business Needs
The company’s chief operating officer wants to reduce waste by 3-5% and cut customer returns by 30% by the end of the current financial year.
Strategy
For this organization, a combination of Lean and Six Sigma tools and methods is appropriate. Lean will eliminate waste and increase process flow to achieve the goal of 3-5% waste reduction. Six Sigma will address variation and defects in the company’s processes and products to achieve customer returns reduction target of 30%. Although this strategy requires a major investment in time and money, the company leadership is prepared to make it.