As a businessperson in the twenty-first century, you’re probably very familiar with the concept of continuous improvement – the consistent and ongoing effort to improve processes, products, or services. And as a certified Six Sigma Black Belt, you will be responsible for showing your company the way to increasing quality and decreasing costs.
In this chapter, you will study the foundation and a brief history of various approaches that eventually led to the evolution of Lean and Six Sigma.
The Industrial Revolution and the advent of machines changed the early concept of quality, which was considered hit or miss and largely determined by the skills of individual craftsmen. Since the 1800s, continual innovations in the means of production – tools and machines – resulted in an explosive growth in the production of goods that has continued to this day.
Accompanying this innovation in the means of production is an evolution in the tools, methods, techniques, and approaches used for quality control and continuous process improvement.
Many events, approaches, methods, and tools are important in the history of continuous process improvement. Five important events include the following:
- the plan-do-check-act (PDCA) cycle
- statistical process control (SPC)
- quality circles
- total quality management (TQM) and ISO 9000
- Baldrige Criteria for Performance Excellence
Two important methods were developed in the 1920s:
PDCA Cycle
The PDCA cycle was developed by W.S. Shewhart in the 1920s. Later improved by Deming, PDCA is an iterative problem-solving loop that is the basis for nearly all continuous process improvement approaches, especially Lean manufacturing.
Control Charts
Shewhart control charts were invented as a way to control process variation. Later, control charts became the basis of statistical process control (SPC), an important element in continuous process improvement.
From your Green Belt studies, you should already be familiar with these seven pioneers of the quality sciences:
- Dr. Walter Shewhart
- Dr. W. Edwards Deming
- Dr. Joseph Juran
- Dr. Kaoru Ishikawa
- Dr. Genichi Taguchi
- Dr. Armand Feigembaum
- Philip Crosby
The quality sciences received a boost during the Second World War. The U.S. Army adopted control charts and statistical techniques to help in the manufacture of arms, equipment, ships, planes, and other warfare needs.
After the war, the quality of U.S. products fell by the wayside as American companies abandoned quality in their pursuit of higher profits.
At the same time, the quality movement traveled to Japan. Drs. Deming and Juran, among others, went to Japan after the war to help the Japanese people stimulate the economy.
Adapting what they learned, engineers at Toyota devised a comprehensive methodology known as the Toyota Production System. A forerunner of Lean manufacturing, this system focused on eliminating waste, reducing inventory, and speeding up processing time.
In addition, Toyota engineers learned how to tap into the power of their workforce for continuous process improvement. They invented quality circles – independent teams of six to eight workers who meet periodically to identify opportunities for improvement and submit them to management.
By the 1980s, using the new manufacturing methodology, Japanese industries were decimating what were considered to be traditionally American markets. U.S. industries scrambled to find ways to meet the challenge. The following continuous improvement methodologies rose to prominence during this time:
Total Quality Management (TQM)
TQM was invented in Japan in the 1950s. However, it achieved prominence in the U.S. in the 1980s. TQM is a comprehensive set of management practices and tools that focuses intensively on meeting or exceeding customer requirements. TQM emphasizes process measurement and controls and seeks to involve all employees in process improvement.
ISO 9000
ISO 9000 is a set of standards that helps businesses to organize for producing high-quality goods. Companies certified as ISO 9000-compliant conduct business locally and internationally with an assurance of an agreed-upon quality level.
Both TQM and ISO 9000 helped many companies “trim the fat” and improve quality. However, there were still many U.S. companies that didn’t want to spend time and money on quality.
Recognizing a potentially disastrous consequence of this attitude, the U.S. Congress took action. It established the Malcolm Baldrige National Quality Award in an attempt to inspire companies to achieve higher quality. The award is given annually to companies that exemplify innovation, excellence, and world-class performance. The Baldrige Criteria for Performance Excellence are published by the National Institute of Standards (NIST) to provide guidance for companies that seek to establish excellence in performance management.
Evolution is messy. Ideas sometimes appear long before they’re used, and it’s sometimes difficult to pinpoint when events occurred. But in describing the evolution of Lean and Six Sigma, understanding the order in which continuous improvement approaches gained prominence in the quality sciences is important.
PDCA Cycle: PDCA appeared in the 1920s.
Statistical Process Control (SPC): Statistical process control was in widespread use in the 1960s.
Quality Circles: Quality circles were adopted by many U.S. manufacturers by the early 1980s.
Total quality management (TQM) / ISO 9000: TQM and ISO 9000 appeared in the mid-1980s.
Baldrige Criteria for Performance Excellence: The Baldrige Criteria for Performance Excellence were first published in the late 1980s.
In the late 1980s and the 1990s, work in the quality sciences intensified. Additional methods or approaches that occurred during this time include:
- benchmarking
- re-engineering
- balanced scorecard
- Six Sigma
- Lean
Benchmarking is a strategy for improving the organization by adopting applicable best practices of industry leaders. Benchmarking helps an organization to identify what it does well and not so well, and emulate and adapt the leaders’ processes in order to achieve superior performance levels.
Benchmarking did not influence the evolution of Six Sigma directly. However, benchmarking became a widely accepted method in Six Sigma for setting improvement goals and for identifying best practices and improvement solutions in order to deliver superior products and processes.
Re-engineering is a method for streamlining the organization. By the 1990s, many companies built according to the traditional pyramid structure were top-heavy and populated with turf-guarding, empire-building executives. Rigid divisional boundaries protected the status quo and prevented innovation.
In their 1993 book “Reengineering the Corporation: A Manifesto for Business Revolution,” Michael Hammer and James Champy urged senior management to throw everything out and build back with less staff and on the basis of processes rather than along functional lines. The re-engineering movement successfully streamlined many organizations. It also resulted in massive layoffs.
The balanced scorecard is a method of aligning business activities to the vision and strategy of the organization. The balanced scorecard improves internal and external communications and monitors organizational performance against strategic goals.
The balanced scorecard is based on work done in France and at General Electric in the 1950s, but it was popularized by Robert S. Kaplan and David P. Norton in their 1996 book “The Balanced Scorecard.”
In the face of bitter competition from Japan in the early and mid-1980s, Motorola created a new quality initiative from elements in the mainstream quality control movement. Motorola called its invention Six Sigma. Popularized by Jack Welch at General Electric in the mid-1990s, Six Sigma is one of the world’s most popular continuous improvement methodologies.
Six Sigma uses continuous improvement techniques and a specialized toolkit to drive products and services to near perfection by reducing variation and defects through the application of sophisticated statistical techniques.
The Toyota Production System developed in Japan in the 1950s and 1960s continued to fascinate quality engineers into the 1990s. By 2000, U.S. organizations had sufficient experience with the methods and tools to successfully implement the methodology, now renamed Lean.
Lean focuses on manufacturing without waste. Its tools are used to reduce waste, cost, and cycle time, and improve process flow. Lean is also being used successfully in non-manufacturing concerns.
Focus on quality improvement intensified during the late 1980s and 1990s, reaching an evolutionary apex with Six Sigma and Lean.